Random toughts on "Nahual" by Peregrine
Dec. 8th, 2003 07:11 amMy life partner was at home a few days and occupied the TV-Set, which meant no taping, no random thoughts on eps. So I read a little. "Nahual" by Peregrine, a gen story and fairly long, it can be found here: http://home.earthlink.net/~ktutt/index.html
I liked it. I really liked it. Which is a little surprising, since I'm usually not all too fond of shape-shifting in TS because I think of it as very AU.
This story isn't really an AU. *g* See, the series gave us all those scenes which showed us something unusual and mysterical going on with Jim and Blair, despite the fact that they're guys firmly rooted in the here and now. Especially the first eps of every season were made this way and it became more mystical with each season-beginning.
Switchman, Flight, Warriors and Sen Too are the continuing story of the development of Jim-the-Sentinel and Blair-his partner. Each of this eps contains a significant development of Jim's Sentinel-side and his relationship with Blair.
In Switchman he got the senses back and Sandburg talks him into the diss-deal. It's the start of their journey.
In Flight he made the choice to continue being a sentinel and Blair made the decision to stay with Jim instead of going on this expedition in Borneo. Jim's big step is easy to see, Visions, choices etc, all clearly here to see, but Blair's decision seems to be of less significance at first sight. But it is truely a decision for Jim and against his own career. It was at this early stage in the series that Blair chose his place on Jim's side over his own academic way. I doubt that he was aware of this little fact, but I'm firmly convinced that the decision we see in TSbyBS made consciously by Blair, was already made unconsciously in this ep. He didn't acknowledge it and I think he didn't *want* to acknowledge that for a long time, but the course was set in this ep.
In Warriors, Jim has to face several crisises. First, there's the fact that his senses played a trick at him and lured him into shooting an innocent, which leaves him with the wish to lose his senses because they can cause danger to innocent persons, at least that's how he sees it. Second, Jim has to chose again, this time between his duty as the sentinel of the Chopec-tribe, his past, and his duty as a modern sentinel of Cascade in his function as a police-officer, his future. Third, Incacha dies and his death is linked to the case and how Jim handled it. If he had obeyed Incachas wish, Incacha probably wouldn't have died. So, Jim's decision for "his future", the way he is and works now, in a way caused Incacha's death and therefore the "death of his past". I don't say Jim is to blame for Incacha's death, of course he made the right decision, but I see the symbolism in it. *g* But that's maybe just me. *G*
And let's not forget Blair. In Warriors Incacha passed his own duty on to Blair, the way of the shaman, whatever this means. And again, Jim's decision of how to handle the case also, in a way, "caused" the death of Blair's female friend and therefore a piece of Blair's past died too. Again, I'm not blaming Jim, I'm just playing with "how destiny works" here. *g* So, in the end of the ep we have a Jim who decided on being the sentinel of "the great city" Cascade and he had a partner on his side who bears a duty he has no clue about how to tackle it.
In Sen Too, their relationship was tested the hardest way. We all know what happened. Alex killed Blair, Jim called him back and then went after Alex. Blair got out of the hospital and followed Jim into the jungle without an obvious reason other that he wanted to be near Jim, probably to be there if Jim needed help. Jim underwent a change in the pool, his senses became sharper, I think this is mentioned in a later episode IIRC, and when Incacha talked about the light that has to come from within, Jim sees various visions of Blair. All very mystical and a wide field for interpretations. *g* In the end we have a badly rattled pair but they're still partners and they still *want* to be partners, which is the important point. They were tested, they fought, they won. Scarred and hurt but they won.
It's easy to see how each of those eps enhances the mystical aspect of their relationship and that's where "Nahual" comes in the play. *g*
The story takes place a month after Sen Too but if the series had continued, we would have gotten a few more case-eps after Sen Too and "Nahual" could have been easily the season five-opener. It's absolutely in the tradition of the mystical season-opener eps. :-)
It has a neat case, it has big mystical things happening and it ends with Jim and Blair on a new level of their relationship. Peregrine ties her story neatly to canon-facts and I find her take on it very, very good. "This" is how the series *could* have continued after Sen Too and the reason why the story doesn't feel overly AUish to me. Her guys have canon-character regarding their behavior and the way how they handled the things happening.
She ties in Jim's "I shot the wolf"-vison and makes it significant for the story and their behavior and she made sense of Jim's "This is not me"-cry in the pool. And Blair's after-drowning feelings are pretty believable, kind of logical and important for the story. She took the incidents we saw in Sen Too and *developed* her story from this point. Both guys are struggling with the things happening. Jim with his new ability/curse, Blair with his new "duty" as a shaman, although it's not overstressed. I like it how she makes Blair struggling so naturally with the things thrown at him. He's not a "I know all, I understand all and I'm perfectly sure" immetiately. He has to work and to fight to get his clues, it isn't a shinging crown thrown in his lap. And he's simply Blair while he does this.
A few times I really feared she would fall into the "saint Blair"-trap, but she managed to avoid that. :-) In her story isn't one to blame, both guys are to blame or not, depenting on how you want to see it. In this also, she stays in the "tradition" of the series-eps. She weaves a complex pattern of Jim and Blair's relationship and in the end, there isn't one of them being the winner or the one in charge. They both win and lose in reaching this new stage of their relationship.
I find her style very strong and expressive, although I have to say, it reads unusal to me. And this is the point where I get a little insecure. I'm not good enough with English to judge whether Peregrine isn't a native speaker and this is why her writing sounds this unusual for me or whether she simply has an unusal but correct style. I found a few typos and some things where I though "that's gramatically wrong" but as I said, I'm not good enough to be really able to judge that.
This may be a point that could lessen the fun of reading for a native speaker, I simply don't know it. To me, it read fluid and expressive and exactly this is, what makes me suspicious. *g* It could easily be that I like this because some of her expressions sound so familiar to me that I got the impression her native language might be close to mine than to English. Either this, or she's simply an unusal author. *G*
I liked it. I really liked it. Which is a little surprising, since I'm usually not all too fond of shape-shifting in TS because I think of it as very AU.
This story isn't really an AU. *g* See, the series gave us all those scenes which showed us something unusual and mysterical going on with Jim and Blair, despite the fact that they're guys firmly rooted in the here and now. Especially the first eps of every season were made this way and it became more mystical with each season-beginning.
Switchman, Flight, Warriors and Sen Too are the continuing story of the development of Jim-the-Sentinel and Blair-his partner. Each of this eps contains a significant development of Jim's Sentinel-side and his relationship with Blair.
In Switchman he got the senses back and Sandburg talks him into the diss-deal. It's the start of their journey.
In Flight he made the choice to continue being a sentinel and Blair made the decision to stay with Jim instead of going on this expedition in Borneo. Jim's big step is easy to see, Visions, choices etc, all clearly here to see, but Blair's decision seems to be of less significance at first sight. But it is truely a decision for Jim and against his own career. It was at this early stage in the series that Blair chose his place on Jim's side over his own academic way. I doubt that he was aware of this little fact, but I'm firmly convinced that the decision we see in TSbyBS made consciously by Blair, was already made unconsciously in this ep. He didn't acknowledge it and I think he didn't *want* to acknowledge that for a long time, but the course was set in this ep.
In Warriors, Jim has to face several crisises. First, there's the fact that his senses played a trick at him and lured him into shooting an innocent, which leaves him with the wish to lose his senses because they can cause danger to innocent persons, at least that's how he sees it. Second, Jim has to chose again, this time between his duty as the sentinel of the Chopec-tribe, his past, and his duty as a modern sentinel of Cascade in his function as a police-officer, his future. Third, Incacha dies and his death is linked to the case and how Jim handled it. If he had obeyed Incachas wish, Incacha probably wouldn't have died. So, Jim's decision for "his future", the way he is and works now, in a way caused Incacha's death and therefore the "death of his past". I don't say Jim is to blame for Incacha's death, of course he made the right decision, but I see the symbolism in it. *g* But that's maybe just me. *G*
And let's not forget Blair. In Warriors Incacha passed his own duty on to Blair, the way of the shaman, whatever this means. And again, Jim's decision of how to handle the case also, in a way, "caused" the death of Blair's female friend and therefore a piece of Blair's past died too. Again, I'm not blaming Jim, I'm just playing with "how destiny works" here. *g* So, in the end of the ep we have a Jim who decided on being the sentinel of "the great city" Cascade and he had a partner on his side who bears a duty he has no clue about how to tackle it.
In Sen Too, their relationship was tested the hardest way. We all know what happened. Alex killed Blair, Jim called him back and then went after Alex. Blair got out of the hospital and followed Jim into the jungle without an obvious reason other that he wanted to be near Jim, probably to be there if Jim needed help. Jim underwent a change in the pool, his senses became sharper, I think this is mentioned in a later episode IIRC, and when Incacha talked about the light that has to come from within, Jim sees various visions of Blair. All very mystical and a wide field for interpretations. *g* In the end we have a badly rattled pair but they're still partners and they still *want* to be partners, which is the important point. They were tested, they fought, they won. Scarred and hurt but they won.
It's easy to see how each of those eps enhances the mystical aspect of their relationship and that's where "Nahual" comes in the play. *g*
The story takes place a month after Sen Too but if the series had continued, we would have gotten a few more case-eps after Sen Too and "Nahual" could have been easily the season five-opener. It's absolutely in the tradition of the mystical season-opener eps. :-)
It has a neat case, it has big mystical things happening and it ends with Jim and Blair on a new level of their relationship. Peregrine ties her story neatly to canon-facts and I find her take on it very, very good. "This" is how the series *could* have continued after Sen Too and the reason why the story doesn't feel overly AUish to me. Her guys have canon-character regarding their behavior and the way how they handled the things happening.
She ties in Jim's "I shot the wolf"-vison and makes it significant for the story and their behavior and she made sense of Jim's "This is not me"-cry in the pool. And Blair's after-drowning feelings are pretty believable, kind of logical and important for the story. She took the incidents we saw in Sen Too and *developed* her story from this point. Both guys are struggling with the things happening. Jim with his new ability/curse, Blair with his new "duty" as a shaman, although it's not overstressed. I like it how she makes Blair struggling so naturally with the things thrown at him. He's not a "I know all, I understand all and I'm perfectly sure" immetiately. He has to work and to fight to get his clues, it isn't a shinging crown thrown in his lap. And he's simply Blair while he does this.
A few times I really feared she would fall into the "saint Blair"-trap, but she managed to avoid that. :-) In her story isn't one to blame, both guys are to blame or not, depenting on how you want to see it. In this also, she stays in the "tradition" of the series-eps. She weaves a complex pattern of Jim and Blair's relationship and in the end, there isn't one of them being the winner or the one in charge. They both win and lose in reaching this new stage of their relationship.
I find her style very strong and expressive, although I have to say, it reads unusal to me. And this is the point where I get a little insecure. I'm not good enough with English to judge whether Peregrine isn't a native speaker and this is why her writing sounds this unusual for me or whether she simply has an unusal but correct style. I found a few typos and some things where I though "that's gramatically wrong" but as I said, I'm not good enough to be really able to judge that.
This may be a point that could lessen the fun of reading for a native speaker, I simply don't know it. To me, it read fluid and expressive and exactly this is, what makes me suspicious. *g* It could easily be that I like this because some of her expressions sound so familiar to me that I got the impression her native language might be close to mine than to English. Either this, or she's simply an unusal author. *G*